[Film Review] David Gilmour – Live in Pompeii

Live at PompeiiScreened in some two thousand cinemas worldwide on September 13th, David Gilmour’s Live at Pompeii is an impressive concert film in every aspect. We had a ticket for one of those screenings, and here’s what we thought.

David Gilmour doesn’t have to do anything if he doesn’t feel like it. With the Pink Floyd chapter closed for good with The Endless River, the legendary guitarist can rest assuredly on his laurels, and seems to do just that most of the time. In between, and if we’re lucky, we get treated to some solo material, lastly in the form of the very enjoyable Rattle that Lock. Gilmour subsequently went on tour to promote the album, and chose to do so in smaller venues with a more special feel. With a capacity of about two thousand spectators, the amphitheatre in Pompeii was the smallest of those, but surely the most impressive.

It had been 45 years since Gilmour first played the amphitheatre, then as part of the Pink Floyd outfit, 45 years younger, shirtless in the searing heat and without an audience other than band and crew. 71 years old now, the guitarist looks nothing like his younger counterpart in a short interview segment leading up to the concert. A matured, older man, he seems content with doing things like this on a semi-regular basis when he feels like it. He’s surrounded himself with an impressive backing band that seems to relish in playing together. I for one can’t remember any footage of Pink Floyd ever having much fun on stage, properly interacting with one another. On stage, however, it’s still the same David Gilmour. Balder, more scruffy looking, but his vocals and guitar work remains nearly unchanged.

Pompeii is properly impressive. I’ve had the pleasure of going there once, years ago (although our group completely missed visiting the amphitheatre for some sad reason), and seeing the stage set up in the middle of the ancient ruins with mount Vesuvius looming large in the background is a spectacular sight to behold. You wonder why this is the first proper event held there before an audience since before Vesuvius erupted (the first audience since the gladiators, as Gilmour boasts in the preceding segment). The locale is simply magnificent, and the theatre is lit very impressively, with the stage and the ever-present round projection screen being at the centre of it.

When the gig starts off with 5 A.M. and Rattle that Lock (both of Gilmour’s last album), the first thought running through your head is, “oh yeah, this isn’t proper Pink Floyd.” Not that the man’s solo material is bad (far from it), but next to the legacy of Floyd it can seem more forgettable. I for one wasn’t all that disappointed to find out they had made a number of cuts for tonight’s screening, leaving out most of the solo stuff in favour of all the classic Floyd material. The sense of relief when the band tears into What Do You Want from Me (from The Division Bell) is palpable. What’s kept from the latest album is the beautiful A Boat Lies Waiting, which is dedicated to Floyd keyboardist Richard Wright, who passed away in 2008, and the fantastic In Any Tongue, which definitely benefits from the amplified live performance here.

Rick Wright looms big over the entire evening. You get a sense that Shine On You Crazy Diamond is more about him tonight than it is about Syd Barrett, and the version of Great Gig in the Sky played here is utterly phenomenal, with the vocal arrangement shared by the three backing singers, of which particularly Lucita Jules makes a lasting impression with some truly impressive vocal work whilst Gilmour sits behind his console steel guitar like some mad wizard. 

As Gilmour states at the beginning, Pompeii is a place of ghosts, and you can feel Wright’s ghost lingering over the evening here. Noticeably absent for that same reason is Echoes, the conversation between Rick and David (as Gilmour states himself) which can no longer be held. Instead we get an impressive amount of choice Floyd cuts, amongst which the ominous High Hopes, an electrifying version of One of These Days, Run Like Hell with a hell of a lot of pyrotechnics, Breathe (from the masterpiece that is Dark Side of the Moon) and, of course, Comfortably Numb, before the proverbial curtain comes down.

The band is in fine form, and especially Gilmour seems to be having the time of his life here. It’s good to see a motivated and stellar band working their way through these classics, and the atmosphere provided by the location only adds to the experience. Nothing beats a setting like Pompeii, and the visuals are spectacular throughout. The lighting is fantastic and, during Run Like Hell, so blindingly bright that the entire band is forced to wear sunglasses. It’s a visual spectacle you would only expect from someone like Gilmour or Waters, and Live at Pompeii does not disappoint one iota in that respect.

Live at Pompeii is out on DVD, Blu-ray, LP and CD later this month, this is mandatory fare for the fans of Gilmour’s solo stuff as well as the most casual of Pink Floyd fans.

Label: Sony Music
Release: 29/09/2017

DVD/Blu-ray Track listing:

  1. 5 A.M.
  2. Rattle That Lock
  3. Faces of Stone
  4. What Do You Want from Me
  5. The Blue
  6. The Great Gig in the Sky
  7. A Boat Lies Waiting
  8. Wish You Were Here
  9. Money
  10. In Any Tongue
  11. High Hopes
  12. One of These Days
  13. Shine On You Crazy Diamond
  14. Fat Old Sun
  15. Coming Back to Life
  16. On an Island
  17. The Girl in the Yellow Dress
  18. Today
  19. Sorrow
  20. Run Like Hell
  21. Breathe
  22. Comfortably Numb


  • David Gilmour – electric guitars, acoustic guitars, classical guitar, console steel guitar, lead vocals, cymbals on “One of These Days”, whistling on “In Any Tongue”
  • Chester Kamen – electric guitars, acoustic guitars, 12-string acoustic guitar, backing vocals, harmonica on “The Blue”
  • Guy Pratt – bass guitars, double bass, backing vocals, lead vocals on “Run Like Hell”
  • Greg Phillinganes – keyboards, backing vocals, lead vocals on “Time”
  • Chuck Leavell – keyboards, accordion, backing vocals, lead vocals on “Comfortably Numb”
  • Steve DiStanislao – drums, percussion, backing vocals, aeoliphone on “One of These Days”
  • João Mello – saxophones, clarinet, additional keyboards on “The Blue”, high-strung acoustic guitar on “In Any Tongue”
  • Bryan Chambers – backing vocals, additional percussion, lead vocals on “In Any Tongue”
  • Lucita Jules – backing vocals, lead vocals on “The Great Gig in the Sky”
  • Louise Clare Marshall – backing vocals, additional percussion, lead vocals on “The Great Gig in the Sky”

Further surfing:

Review by Ralph Plug


One thought on “[Film Review] David Gilmour – Live in Pompeii

  1. Pingback: [Live Review] Roger Waters: Us + Them Tour, Ziggo Dome Amsterdam | soundsfromthedarkside

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s